Organisation of Aware Saviours In Society

Of the Students, For the Students, By the Students

Tata Motors Report


Review Report – C D Deshmukh Udyan (March 2016)

Submitted to
 tata motors logo

Report by: Dr. V.Shubhalaxmi

Founder & CEO
Ladybird Environmental Consulting LLP
22 March 2016

 oasis logo ladybird logo

Review Report (March 2016)


In collaboration with OASIS, a tree plantation project was implemented by Tata Motors Ltd. wherein 14,000 saplings were planted for creating habitats supporting local biodiversity. 7000 saplings were planted at Maharashtra Nature Park and 7000 at CD Deshmukh Udyan. In the first year 52% mortality was reported and 1000 saplings were replanted at MNP. And 8% mortality was reported and 1800 saplings were replanted at CD Deshmukh Udyan.

This is the second year of the project and the first project report for 2016. Currently the habitat is looking dry at MNP and there has been approximately 75% of mortality with surviving plants are 1767 out of  7000 saplings planted. And 56%  of mortality with surviving plants are 2836 out of 7000 saplings planted at CD Deshmukh Udyan. A total 24 species of butterflies were observed at the Maharashtra Nature Park (MNP) and 6 species at the C.D. Deshmukh Udyan.  The plants like Periwinkle, Jamaican Blue Spike, Pentas were in full bloom. However the butterfly population at the C.D. Deshmukh Udyan has gone down compared to the last report. It was observed that both the sites are facing water shortage problem. As a remedy, we will develop saplings from the mature plants during the monsoon and compensate for the mortality.


This report is based on three review visits on 22 December 2015, 9 February 2016, and 5 March 2016, at MNP and 9 February 2016, 6 March 2016 at the C.D. Deshmukh Udyan.

1.1 Maharashtra Nature Park (MNP):

A review visit was conducted on 22 December 2015, 9 February 2016, and 5 March 2016, at the Maharashtra Nature Park site to check the plant growth. During the visits it was observed that the habitat was looking dry and the ground was covered with leaf litter. It was observed that there was a watering issue at the site. The deweeding activity was done in both the plots. Plants like Pentas, Jamaican Blue Spike and Periwinkle were seen flowering during the last visit on 5 March 2016.



A sapling count was also done on 5 March 2016 by Ms Priti Choghale, Project Manager, LEC  with the help of  volunteers to check  the survival rate  of  the saplings.  It  was observed that 1764 saplings were surviving. It was also observed the few plants which were thought to be dead earlier like Madhumalti have sprouted back and also few laburnum saplings. Also new shoots of Bryophyllum were seen growing. The list of Plants with the survival rate in attached as Annexure 1  and comparative photographs as Annexure 2

Following are detail observations, plot wise.

Plot 1: It looked very dry with ground covered with dry leaves. It seemed as if the plants were not watered regularly. The Jamaican Blue spikes saplings were looking wilted. There were empty patches observed in the plot as seen in the images. The same could be the result of deweeding. The plants like Pentas, Jamaican Blue Spike, Periwinkle and Plumbago were flowering. It was observed that the leaves of the Laburnum saplings were eaten by caterpillars indicating the presence of caterpillars in the habitat. The Bryophyllum saplings too showed the sign of caterpillars feeding on them. New shoots of Bryophyllum were observed and have covered the ground making a carpet. Overall the habitat is established inspite of loss of plants.


Plot 2: The plants are growing well in the Plot 2 however the growth rate. Also this area being open from all sides is vulnerable to cattle attack. The MNP officials have been informed about the status of the plots on timely basis. Due to human resource and water shortage, they are unable to take care of all green zones at MNP.

1.2 C.D. Deshmukh Udyan

It was observed that the overall saplings which have survived are flourishing well and Periwinkle was in full bloom. The plants like Jamaican Blue Spike which were trimmed have grown back and have started flowering. However the garden was facing water shortage for past two months which has affected the plants drastically. The replantation work which was pending has been completed.


A total of 2836 saplings were counted during the visit and are surviving. The list of Plants with the survival rate in attached as Annexure 1 and Plot wise photographs are attached as Annexure 2

A sapling count was done on 6th  March 2016 to check the survival rate of plants. Ms. Priti Choghale, Project Manager and Ms. Prabha Vannier, Environment Officer, LEC conducted the count.


A total of 30 species of butterflies were observed at MNP and C.D. Deshmukh Udyan.

2.1 MNP: The butterfly survey was carried out at MNP during the review visits and 24 species of butterflies were observed during the survey. Following is the list of butterflies sighted.

Sr. No. Butterfly Name Number of Butterflies
1 Blue Tiger 8
2 Common Castor 10
3 Common Cerulean 5
4 Common Crow 1
5 Common Emigrant 2
6 Common Gull 4
7 Tailed Jay 1
8 Common Lineblue 2
9 Common Pierrot 3
10 Common Wanderer 9
11 Lemon Pansy 1
12 Lime Butterfly 1
13 Pea Blue 2
14 Plain Tiger 4
15 Plains Cupid 8
16 Psyche 12
17 Red Pierrot 2
18 Rounded Pierrot 2
19 Small Salman Arab 9
20 Small Cupid 7
21 Striped Tiger 11
22 Twany Coster 13
23 Zebra Blue 70
24 Gram Blue 1
  Total 188


2.2C.D.Deshmukh Udyan: The butterfly count had reduced due to harsh summer and the area had been dry for almost two months. We observed 6 species of butterflies during the review visit. However we made first observation of life history of Red Pierrot Butterfly on Bryophyllum.

Following is the list of butterflies sighted during the visit

Sr. No. Butterfly Name Number of Butterflies
1 Red Pierrot 1
2 Grass Yellow 1
3 Common Emigrant 1
4 Common Mormon 1
5 Tailed Jay 1
6 Blue 1
  Total 6

Butterfly predators such as Calotes were also observed hiding among Jamaican Blue Spike plant, trying to catch the prey and thus completing the food chain in the habitat. Other insects like carpenter bee and dragonflies were observed hovering on the flowers and basking on the plants.

3. Challenges

  • Plant Count: As the plantation was done with an aim of developing an ecosystem therefore  the  plants  were  planted  closely.  After  a  year,  one  could  see  the ecosystem is well established, however the challenge is to count the creepers, climbers and stragglers which have overgrown on each other making the count difficult. Monsoon will be the right time to assess the growth of the habitat as many dying plants may spring back.
  • Water Shortage: There is a water shortage experienced at both the sites and there is a concern over survival of the plantation till monsoon. The authorities at both the sites are managing larger green spaces including our butterfly habitat so the impact of water shortage is affecting overall green spaces managed by them. The concerned departments are have their internal issues to deal therefore seeking an exclusive focus to our habitats is getting difficult. Additionally the project did not have  budget  allocation  for  after  care  therefore we  are  dependent  on  the  site partners who are trying their best but are falling short for various internal problems which we cannot be aware of.
  • Mortality Compensation: As a remedy, we will develop saplings from the mature plants during the monsoon and compensate for any mortality. The clippings of most of the species planted in the habitat could be used for making new saplings.


The survival rate of sapling has gone down due to the watering issues at both the sites. The site partners have agreed that they will take care of the issues however during the summer season due to the harsh heat there may be a decrease in the survival rate. Fortunately most of the plants can be grown by cuttings. Hence the dead ones can be replaced by cuttings on the onset of monsoon.

ANNEXURE 1: Plant Survival List

1. Plant Survival list at MNP Particular Type Category Qty Survival Replantation 04-03-2016
1 Periwinkle Nectar Herb 400 400   50
2 Bryophyllum (pan phutti) Foodplant Herb 200 150   150
3 Widelia Climber Herb 200 100   0
4 Lantana (white) Nectar Shrub 250 150   3
5 Lanata (yellow – erect species) Nectar Shrub 250 150   26
6 Lantana red spreading species Nectar Shrub 300 200   13
7 Lantana purple spreading species Nectar Shrub 300 200   0
8 Giant milkweed (Rui) Foodplant Shrub 20 10   0
9 Blue Plumbago Nectar Shrub 200 100   85
10 Pentas (pink, white, red) Nectar Shrub 300 200   115
11 Jamaican spike
Nectar Shrub 1000 500 200 340
12 Passion flower (Krishnakamal) Foodplant Shrub 200 200   0
13 Tagar Foodplant Shrub 225 0   10
14 Kufia Nectar Shrub 250 50   23
15 Mini ixora (pink, red) Nectar Shrub 300 50   0
16 Mini ixora (white) Nectar Shrub 30 0   0
17 Sontakka Nectar Shrub 40 0   0
18 Red ixora Nectar Tree 200 50   24
19 Nirgudi Nectar Tree 100 50   46
20 Hamelia Nectar Tree 300 100 200 194
21 Pongam Foodplant Tree 165 50   24
22 Lemon (limbu)seedling Foodplant Tree 150 0   9
23 Curry leaf (kaddipatta) Foodplant Tree 300 50 200 50
24 Pink oleander (kanher) Foodplant Tree 200 100 200 281
25 Mussaenda ( pink ) Foodplant Tree 100 0   0
26 Indian laburnum (Bahava) Foodplant Tree 110 50   56
27 Mast tree (Ashoka) Foodplant Tree 200 50   10
28 Fan palm (table) Foodplant Tree 200 15 200 10
29 Shankasur ( yellow, orange, pink) Foodplant Tree 500 400   244
30 Madhumalti Foodplant Tree 10 0   1
  Total     7000 3375 1000 1767


2. Plant Survival List at C.D. Deshmukh Udyan Particular Type Category Qty Survival Replantation 04-Mar-16
1 Periwinkle Nectar Herb 365 365   47
2 Bryophyllum (Pan Phutti) Foodplant Herb 200 200   57
3 Widelia Climber Herb 600 600 500 200
4 Lantana (White spreading) Nectar Shrub 375 375 200 0
5 Lanata (yellow – erect species) Nectar Shrub 115 115   23
6 Lantana Red Erect species Nectar Shrub 100 100   0
7 Lantana Purple spreading species Nectar Shrub 430 430 200 160
8 Blue Plumbago Nectar Shrub 225 225   35
9 Pentas (Pink, White, Red) Nectar Shrub 285 200   111
10 Jamaican Spike (Stachytarpeta) Nectar Shrub 1000 900 700 462
11 Tagar Foodplant Shrub 100 15 200 138
12 Kufia Nectar Shrub 200 150   110
13 Mini Ixora (Pink, Red) Nectar Shrub 290 200   0
14 Red Ixora Nectar Tree 300 250   100
15 Areca Palm Foodplant Tree 150 150   64
16 Hamelia Nectar Tree 450 450   167
17 Indian Laburnum Foodplant Tree 115 115   77
18 Curry leaf (Kaddipatta) Foodplant Tree 300 300   139
19 Pink Oleander (Kanher) Foodplant Tree 350 300   300
20 Mussaenda ( Pink ) Foodplant Tree 150 150   61
21 Fan Palm (Table) Foodplant Tree 300 300   131
22 Shankasur ( Yellow, Orange, Pink) Foodplant Tree 600 550   454
  Total     7000 6440 1800 2836